11-Apr-10 WPS 2010 - M.1 | Season | Gotham | 1-0 | Red Stars | | Unkel, T |
25-Apr-10 WPS 2010 - M.3 | Season | Red Stars | 0-1 | Gotham | | Domka |
10-Jul-10 WPS 2010 - M.14 | Season | Red Stars | 2-0 | Gotham | | Mariscal, F |
01-Aug-10 WPS 2010 - M.19 | Season | Gotham | 1-2 | Red Stars | | Radford, D |
08-May-13 NWSL 2013 - M.2 | Regular Season | Gotham | 1-1 | Red Stars | | Mednikov |
10-Aug-13 NWSL 2013 - M.21 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 3-3 | Gotham | | Salazar, K |
07-May-14 NWSL 2014 - M.7 | Regular Season | Gotham | 1-1 | Red Stars | | Chavdarov |
15-Jun-14 NWSL 2014 - M.18 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 2-2 | Gotham | | Duncan, J |
02-May-15 NWSL 2015 - M.4 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 1-0 | Gotham | | Franz |
28-Jun-15 NWSL 2015 - M.11 | Regular Season | Gotham | 0-3 | Red Stars | | Abt |
12-Aug-15 NWSL 2015 - M.21 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 1-1 | Gotham | | Kelley |
29-May-16 NWSL 2016 - M.7 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 1-1 | Gotham | | Franz |
27-Aug-16 NWSL 2016 - M.16 | Regular Season | Gotham | 1-3 | Red Stars | | Chesky |
25-Jun-17 NWSL 2017 - M.10 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 2-1 | Gotham | | Abt |
15-Jul-17 NWSL 2017 - M.14 | Regular Season | Gotham | 2-2 | Red Stars | | Hullner |
21-Apr-18 NWSL 2018 - M.5 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 1-1 | Gotham | | Fonseca |
07-Jul-18 NWSL 2018 - M.18 | Regular Season | Gotham | 1-3 | Red Stars | | Peralta |
04-Sep-18 NWSL 2018 - M.19 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 5-0 | Gotham | | Pekmic |
06-Jul-19 NWSL 2019 - M.12 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 1-2 | Gotham | | Martinez, S |
14-Aug-19 NWSL 2019 - M.19 | Regular Season | Gotham | 2-1 | Red Stars | | Snyder |
15-Sep-19 NWSL 2019 - M.24 | Regular Season | Gotham | 0-3 | Red Stars | | Koroleva |
22-Jul-20 NWSL Challenge 2020 - M.6 | Semi-finals | Gotham | 2-3 | Red Stars | | Szpala |
20-Sep-20 NWSL Fall 2020 - M.3 | Northeast | Red Stars | 4-1 | Gotham | | Pagan |
10-Oct-20 NWSL Fall 2020 - M.6 | Northeast | Gotham | 3-1 | Red Stars | | Arroyo |
22-May-21 NWSL 2021 - M.2 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 0-0 | Gotham | | Monroy |
25-Jul-21 NWSL 2021 - M.12 | Regular Season | Gotham | 2-1 | Red Stars | | Nichols |
04-Sep-21 NWSL 2021 - M.18 | Regular Season | Gotham | 0-0 | Red Stars | | Franz |
07-Nov-21 NWSL 2021 - M.25 | First Round | Red Stars | 1-0 | Gotham | | Broadley |
02-Jul-22 NWSL 2022 - M.10 | Regular Season | Gotham | 0-3 | Red Stars | | Corrigan |
07-Aug-22 NWSL 2022 - M.14 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 2-0 | Gotham | | Broadley |
07-May-23 NWSL 2023 - M.6 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 1-2 | Gotham | | Simon |
25-Jun-23 NWSL 2023 - M.13 | Regular Season | Gotham | 2-1 | Red Stars | | Corrigan |
19-May-24 NWSL 2024 - M.10 | Regular Season | Gotham | 2-1 | Red Stars | | Koroleva |
20-Jul-24 NWSL x LigaMX 2024 - M.1 | Group D | Red Stars | 0-0 (4-5) | Gotham | | Beehler |
12-Oct-24 NWSL 2024 - M.24 | Regular Season | Red Stars | 0-2 | Gotham | | Dopka |
04-May-25 NWSL 2025 - M.7 | Regular Season | Gotham | - | Red Stars | | |
01-Aug-25 NWSL 2025 - M.14 | Regular Season | Red Stars | - | Gotham | | |
|