| 26-Aug-95 EPL 1995/1996 - M.3 | | Everton | 2-0 | Southmptn | | Winter, J |
| 16-Nov-96 EPL 1996/1997 - M.13 | | Everton | 7-1 | Southmptn | | Riley |
| 05-Mar-97 EPL 1996/1997 - M.32 | | Southmptn | 2-2 | Everton | | Durkin |
| 02-Nov-97 EPL 1997/1998 - M.13 | | Everton | 0-2 | Southmptn | | Wilkie |
| 07-Mar-98 EPL 1997/1998 - M.29 | | Southmptn | 2-1 | Everton | | Elleray |
| 12-Dec-98 EPL 1998/1999 - M.17 | | Everton | 1-0 | Southmptn | | Wilkie |
| 16-May-99 EPL 1998/1999 - M.38 | | Southmptn | 2-0 | Everton | | Barber |
| 21-Aug-99 EPL 1999/2000 - M.4 | | Everton | 4-1 | Southmptn | | Knight |
| 22-Jan-00 EPL 1999/2000 - M.23 | | Southmptn | 2-0 | Everton | | D'Urso |
| 14-Oct-00 EPL 2000/2001 - M.9 | | Everton | 1-1 | Southmptn | | Elleray |
| 17-Mar-01 EPL 2000/2001 - M.30 | | Southmptn | 1-0 | Everton | | Halsey |
| 02-Dec-01 EPL 2001/2002 - M.15 | | Everton | 2-0 | Southmptn | | Winter, J |
| 20-Apr-02 EPL 2001/2002 - M.36 | | Southmptn | 0-1 | Everton | | Halsey |
| 11-Sep-02 EPL 2002/2003 - M.5 | | Southmptn | 1-0 | Everton | | Bennett |
| 22-Feb-03 EPL 2002/2003 - M.28 | | Everton | 2-1 | Southmptn | | Elleray |
| 19-Oct-03 EPL 2003/2004 - M.9 | | Everton | 0-0 | Southmptn | | Messias |
| 21-Feb-04 EPL 2003/2004 - M.26 | | Southmptn | 3-3 | Everton | | Dowd |
| 16-Oct-04 EPL 2004/2005 - M.9 | | Everton | 1-0 | Southmptn | | Knight |
| 06-Feb-05 EPL 2004/2005 - M.26 | | Southmptn | 2-2 | Everton | | D'Urso |
| 29-Sep-12 EPL 2012/2013 - M.6 | | Everton | 3-1 | Southmptn | | Probert |
| 21-Jan-13 EPL 2012/2013 - M.23 | | Southmptn | 0-0 | Everton | | Swarbrick |
| 29-Dec-13 EPL 2013/2014 - M.19 | | Everton | 2-1 | Southmptn | | Clattenburg |
| 26-Apr-14 EPL 2013/2014 - M.36 | | Southmptn | 2-0 | Everton | | Oliver, M |
| 20-Dec-14 EPL 2014/2015 - M.17 | | Southmptn | 3-0 | Everton | | Moss |
| 04-Apr-15 EPL 2014/2015 - M.31 | | Everton | 1-0 | Southmptn | | Mason |
| 15-Aug-15 EPL 2015/2016 - M.2 | | Southmptn | 0-3 | Everton | | Oliver, M |
| 16-Apr-16 EPL 2015/2016 - M.34 | | Everton | 1-1 | Southmptn | | Pawson |
| 27-Nov-16 EPL 2016/2017 - M.13 | | Southmptn | 1-0 | Everton | | Pawson |
| 28-Nov-16 PL2 2016/2017 - M.11 | | Southmptn | 1-1 | Everton | | Allison |
| 02-Jan-17 EPL 2016/2017 - M.20 | | Everton | 3-0 | Southmptn | | Friend |
| 20-Feb-17 PL2 2016/2017 - M.18 | | Everton | 2-0 | Southmptn | | Backhouse |
| 26-Nov-17 EPL 2017/2018 - M.13 | | Southmptn | 4-1 | Everton | | Friend |
| 05-May-18 EPL 2017/2018 - M.37 | | Everton | 1-1 | Southmptn | | Moss |
| 18-Aug-18 EPL 2018/2019 - M.2 | | Everton | 2-1 | Southmptn | | Mason |
| 02-Oct-18 League Cup 2018/2019 - M.3 | Third Round | Everton | 1-1
(3-4) | Southmptn | | Kavanagh |
| 19-Jan-19 EPL 2018/2019 - M.23 | | Southmptn | 2-1 | Everton | | Scott, G |
| 30-Aug-19 PL2 2019/2020 - M.4 | | Everton U21 | 8-2 | Southmptn U21 | | Speedie |
| 09-Nov-19 EPL 2019/2020 - M.12 | | Southmptn | 1-2 | Everton | | Tierney |
| 06-Jan-20 PL2 2019/2020 - M.14 | | Southmptn U21 | 1-1 | Everton U21 | | Atkin, R |
| 09-Jul-20 EPL 2019/2020 - M.34 | | Everton | 1-1 | Southmptn | | Mason |
| 25-Oct-20 EPL 2020/2021 - M.6 | | Southmptn | 2-0 | Everton | | Friend |
| 01-Mar-21 EPL 2020/2021 - M.26 | | Everton | 1-0 | Southmptn | | Atkinson, M |
| 02-May-21 PL2 2020/2021 - M.26 | | Southmptn U21 | 0-5 | Everton U21 | | Jackson, S |
| 07-May-21 PL2 2020/2021 - M.13 | | Everton U21 | 4-0 | Southmptn U21 | | Marsden |
| 14-Aug-21 EPL 2021/2022 - M.1 | | Everton | 3-1 | Southmptn | | Friend |
| 19-Feb-22 EPL 2021/2022 - M.26 | | Southmptn | 2-0 | Everton | | Madley, A |
| 01-Oct-22 EPL 2022/2023 - M.9 | | Southmptn | 1-2 | Everton | | Marriner |
| 14-Jan-23 EPL 2022/2023 - M.20 | | Everton | 1-2 | Southmptn | | Brooks |
| 04-Dec-23 PL2 2023/2024 - M.9 | League | Everton U21 | 5-0 | Southmptn U21 | | Rollason |
| 17-Sep-24 League Cup 2024/2025 - M.3 | Third Round | Everton | 1-1
(5-6) | Southmptn | | Bond |
| 02-Nov-24 EPL 2024/2025 - M.10 | | Southmptn | 1-0 | Everton | | Madley, A |
| 18-May-25 EPL 2024/2025 - M.37 | | Everton | - | Southmptn | | |
|