| 15-Apr-10 MLS 2010 - M.4 | Conference | Toronto | 2-1 | Philly | | Toledo |
| 17-Jul-10 MLS 2010 - M.16 | Conference | Philly | 2-1 | Toronto | | Hernandez, R |
| 28-May-11 MLS 2011 - M.11 | Conference | Toronto | 2-6 | Philly | | Bratsis |
| 15-Oct-11 MLS 2011 - M.29 | Conference | Philly | 1-1 | Toronto | |  Petrescu |
| 26-May-12 MLS 2012 - M.12 | Regular Season | Toronto | 1-0 | Philly | | Guzman |
| 08-Jul-12 MLS 2012 - M.18 | Regular Season | Philly | 3-0 | Toronto | | Ward, P |
| 15-Sep-12 MLS 2012 - M.28 | Regular Season | Toronto | 1-1 | Philly | | Petrescu |
| 13-Apr-13 MLS 2013 - M.7 | Regular Season | Philly | 1-1 | Toronto | | Stoica, S |
| 01-Jun-13 MLS 2013 - M.14 | Regular Season | Toronto | 1-1 | Philly | | Gamble |
| 05-Oct-13 MLS 2013 - M.32 | Regular Season | Philly | 1-0 | Toronto | | Villarreal |
| 03-Sep-14 MLS 2014 - M.26 | Regular Season | Philly | 1-0 | Toronto | | Rivero |
| 06-Sep-14 MLS 2014 | Regular Season | Toronto | 0-2 | Philly | |  Kelly, A |
| 02-May-15 MLS 2015 - M.9 | Regular Season | Philly | 0-1 | Toronto | | Villarreal |
| 18-Jul-15 MLS 2015 - M.20 | Regular Season | Toronto | 2-1 | Philly | | Gonzalez, J |
| 03-Oct-15 MLS 2015 - M.31 | Regular Season | Toronto | 3-1 | Philly | | Salazar |
| 20-Aug-16 MLS 2016 - M.24 | Regular Season | Philly | 1-3 | Toronto | | Geiger |
| 24-Sep-16 MLS 2016 - M.29 | Regular Season | Toronto | 1-1 | Philly | | Elfath |
| 26-Oct-16 MLS 2016 - M.35 | Knockout Round | Toronto | 3-1 | Philly | | Toledo |
| 11-Mar-17 MLS 2017 - M.2 | Regular Season | Philly | 2-2 | Toronto | | Geiger |
| 23-Aug-17 MLS 2017 - M.25 | Regular Season | Toronto | 3-0 | Philly | | Villarreal |
| 04-May-18 MLS 2018 - M.10 | Regular Season | Toronto | 3-0 | Philly | | Rivero |
| 08-Jun-18 MLS 2018 - M.15 | Regular Season | Philly | 0-2 | Toronto | | Toledo |
| 02-Mar-19 MLS 2019 - M.1 | Regular Season | Philly | 1-3 | Toronto | | Saghafi |
| 11-May-19 MLS 2019 - M.11 | Regular Season | Toronto | 1-2 | Philly | | Touchan |
| 11-Jul-20 MLS 2020 - M.28 | Regular Season | Philly | - | Toronto | | |
| 15-Aug-20 MLS 2020 - M.37 | Regular Season | Toronto | - | Philly | | |
| 03-Oct-20 MLS 2020 - M.11 | Regular Season | Toronto | 2-1 | Philly | | Rivas, V |
| 24-Oct-20 MLS 2020 - M.16 | Regular Season | Philly | 3-0 | Toronto | | |
| 04-Aug-21 MLS 2021 - M.22 | Refular Season | Philly | 3-0 | Toronto | | Unkel, T |
| 27-Oct-21 MLS 2021 - M.43 | Refular Season | Toronto | 2-2 | Philly | | Petrescu |
| 16-Apr-22 MLS 2022 - M.7 | Regular Season | Toronto | 2-1 | Philly | | Chilowicz |
| 09-Oct-22 MLS 2022 - M.34 | Regular Season | Philly | 4-0 | Toronto | | Szpala |
| 22-Apr-23 MLS 2023 - M.9 | Regular Season | Philly | 4-2 | Toronto | | Chilowicz |
| 30-Aug-23 MLS 2023 - M.29 | Regular Season | Toronto | 3-1 | Philly | | Allatin |
| 29-May-24 MLS 2024 - M.16 | Regular Season | Philly | 0-0 | Toronto | | Vazquez |
| 13-Jul-24 MLS 2024 - M.25 | Regular Season | Toronto | 2-1 | Philly | | Chapman |
| 28-May-25 MLS 2025 - M.23 | Regular Season | Toronto | - | Philly | | |
|